The CROSSPATHS project is on its way to create a network of leading Agri-Food research institutions across Europe that will make an impact on the society and economy. To this end, we have prepared this review of the future of Agri-Food research in Europe, so that our project’s strategy aligns with the most pressing issues faced by our continent with regards to food and agriculture.

The agri-food sector stands at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges ranging from climate change and resource depletion to evolving consumer demands and economic pressures. In response, the European Union has emphasized research and innovation, especially under the Horizon Europe or EIT Food programmes to drive sustainable transformation in this sector. This article explores the pivotal trends shaping the agri-food systems in Western Europe, their alignment with Horizon Europe objectives, and their broader implications for future research and policy-making.

1. Emerging Trends in Agri-Food Systems

The agri-food sector in Europe is poised for transformative changes driven by several emerging trends. According to Myriam Preiss et al. (2022), these trends not only reflect the evolving landscape of agriculture and food production but also address pressing global challenges. Here's a detailed look at each of these trends:

1. Digital Agriculture: Utilization of advanced technologies like IoT, AI, and big data analytics to enhance efficiency and sustainability across the food production chain. Digital tools help farmers optimize inputs such as water and fertilizers, improve crop monitoring, and enhance predictive analytics for better decision-making.
2. Bio-Based Economies: Shifting towards an economy where biological resources are sustainably harnessed to produce food, energy, and industrial goods. This trend emphasizes reducing dependency on fossil resources, enhancing the value of agricultural waste, and promoting circularity in production processes.
3. Sustainability and Resource Efficiency: Focused efforts on sustainable practices that reduce environmental impact, such as lowering greenhouse gas emissions, enhancing soil health, and conserving water. This trend is crucial for ensuring the long-term viability of agriculture and food systems.
4. Food Security and Safety: Strengthening food systems to ensure that food is available, accessible, and safe to consume. This includes adopting technologies that improve food traceability, prevent contamination, and enhance the nutritional content of food products.
5. Consumer-Centric Innovations: Developing products and services that align with the evolving preferences and values of consumers, such as organic produce, plant-based proteins, and personalized nutrition plans. This trend is driven by an increased consumer focus on health, ethics, and environmental impact.
6. Agroecology and Sustainable Land Use: Integrating ecological principles into agricultural practices to enhance biodiversity, recycle nutrients, and support ecosystem services. This approach promotes more resilient agricultural systems that can adapt to climate change and reduce ecological footprints.
7. Supply Chain Transparency: Implementing systems and technologies that provide greater transparency and accountability throughout the supply chain. This helps in building trust among consumers and stakeholders, ensuring fair trade practices, and reducing food fraud.
8. Policy and Regulatory Frameworks: Adapting and developing new policies that support innovative practices and technologies in the agri-food sector. This trend includes regulatory adjustments that facilitate market entry for new products, support sustainable practices, and encourage research and development.
9. Cross-Sectoral Collaborations: Encouraging collaborations across different sectors such as technology, finance, and education to foster innovation and address complex challenges in the agri-food sector. These partnerships help leverage diverse expertise and resources, driving systemic changes that are beyond the reach of individual entities.

These trends collectively contribute to a dynamic and adaptive agri-food sector capable of addressing the needs of both current and future generations. By embracing these trends, Europe can lead in creating more sustainable, efficient, and consumer-responsive food systems.

2. Innovation and Technology in Agri-Food

The agri-food sector in Europe is undergoing a significant transformation driven by rapid technological advancements. Insights from R. Jurczak (2021) highlight the necessity of an integrated approach that assesses and forecasts various processes and factors for innovative development. Technological diversity, as underscored by studies from Alessandro Muscio (2018), not only supports the resilience and adaptability of agri-food systems but also enhances their capacity to respond to global changes and market demands.

2.1. Technological Advancements: Smart Farming Solutions

One of the most impactful innovations in the agri-food sector is the emergence of smart farming technologies. These technologies incorporate advanced sensors, big data analytics, and artificial intelligence to optimize the efficiency of farming operations. For instance, precision agriculture tools allow farmers to monitor soil moisture levels, crop health, and weather conditions in real time. This data-driven approach enables precise application of water, fertilizers, and pesticides, reducing waste and environmental impact while increasing crop yields.

Additionally, the integration of blockchain technology in the agri-food sector offers enhanced transparency and traceability in food supply chains. Blockchain enables a secure, immutable record of all transactions from farm to table, ensuring food safety and quality while reducing fraud and increasing consumer trust. An example of this is a pilot project in southern Europe where olive oil producers use blockchain to track the entire production process, providing consumers with verifiable information about the product’s origin and quality.

Robotics also plays a crucial role in transforming agri-food systems. Automated robots are being used for tasks such as planting, harvesting, and packing. These robots not only improve efficiency but also help address labor shortages in agriculture. For example, robotic harvesters in the Netherlands are being used to pick apples and tomatoes, significantly reducing the strain on human labor and enhancing productivity.

Moreover, the application of AI in predictive analytics is revolutionizing how stakeholders anticipate market trends and consumer preferences. AI algorithms analyze vast amounts of data to forecast crop yields, market demand, and pricing fluctuations, helping agri-food businesses make informed decisions that align with market conditions.

2.2. Impact of Technological Integration

The seamless integration of these technologies into the agri-food sector represents a paradigm shift towards more sustainable and resilient food systems. This shift not only improves agricultural output and efficiency but also promotes environmental sustainability by minimizing the sector’s carbon footprint. Furthermore, technological innovation fosters economic growth by creating new job opportunities and opening new markets for sustainable products.

Europe's investment in research and development, coupled with favorable policies and a collaborative ecosystem that includes academia, industry, and government, is crucial for advancing these technologies. The continued focus on technological innovation is essential for maintaining the competitiveness of Europe's agri-food sector in the global economy.

3. Co-creation and Local Development

Co-creation and local development are increasingly recognized as pivotal strategies in transforming agri-food systems. These approaches leverage the collective knowledge, expertise, and energy of various stakeholders, including farmers, researchers, policymakers, and consumers, to innovate and implement sustainable solutions tailored to local needs.

3.1. Engaging Communities in Agri-Food Innovations

The transformation of Brussels' agri-food system, explored by J. Hermesse et al. (2023), exemplifies the power of co-creative research. This initiative has not only addressed urban agriculture challenges but has also made significant strides in improving food distribution and accessibility. By involving local communities in the research process, projects can harness grassroots knowledge and insights, which are critical in designing effective and sustainable agri-food solutions.

Local engagement is facilitated through workshops, town hall meetings, and digital platforms that allow community members to voice their opinions, share their experiences, and contribute to decision-making processes. This participatory approach ensures that the solutions developed are not only innovative but also culturally and contextually appropriate, leading to higher adoption rates and more profound impacts on local food systems.

3.2. Building Local Capacities and Infrastructure

In addition to engaging communities, co-creation in agri-food research focuses on building local capacities and infrastructure that support sustainable practices. For example, educational programs and training workshops equip local farmers and entrepreneurs with the skills and knowledge needed to adopt new technologies and practices that enhance productivity and sustainability. These programs often cover topics such as organic farming, resource-efficient technologies, and sustainable supply chain management.

Moreover, local development initiatives often include the establishment or enhancement of infrastructure that supports agri-food activities. This can include the development of local processing facilities that add value to raw agricultural products, community gardens that promote urban agriculture, and digital marketplaces that connect local producers with consumers directly.

3.3. Fostering Economic Growth and Sustainability

By fostering local economic growth through agri-food initiatives, these co-creative approaches contribute significantly to broader economic and sustainability goals. They stimulate local economies by creating jobs, enhancing food security, and reducing environmental impacts through more localized food production and distribution methods. Furthermore, these initiatives support the resilience of local food systems against global supply chain disruptions by promoting self-sufficiency and reducing dependency on imported foods.

3.4. Impact and Broader Implications

The impacts of co-creation and local development in agri-food systems are profound and far-reaching. By actively involving local stakeholders and tailoring solutions to specific local contexts, these approaches not only enhance the sustainability and resilience of food systems but also foster a sense of community ownership and responsibility towards local and global environmental challenges. Additionally, they set a precedent for how collaborative and inclusive methods can lead to more effective and adaptive solutions in other sectors facing similar sustainability challenges.

4. Impact on Local Economies

Co-creative agri-food initiatives have a transformative impact on local economies by fostering economic growth, enhancing food security, and promoting sustainable practices. These projects not only provide immediate economic benefits by creating jobs and increasing incomes but also contribute to long-term economic resilience by diversifying local economies and reducing dependency on external food sources.

4.1. Economic Diversification through Value-Added Products

One significant way co-creative projects impact local economies is through the development of value-added products. For instance, in regions specializing in dairy production, local stakeholders might collaborate to create new cheese varieties or dairy-based products that cater to niche markets. These initiatives not only increase the value of local agricultural products but also open new market opportunities, both locally and globally. For example, a cooperative in Southern Italy has successfully branded its olive oil and wine products by leveraging local traditions and modern marketing techniques, significantly boosting the region's economic profile.

4.2. Job Creation and Skill Development

Co-creative projects often lead to job creation and skill development within communities. By introducing new technologies and practices, these projects require trained personnel, thus creating jobs and offering local residents opportunities to develop new skills. In the Netherlands, the integration of greenhouse technologies has not only increased agricultural productivity but also led to the creation of specialized jobs in greenhouse management, logistics, and marketing. These jobs often pay better than traditional farming jobs and contribute to a more skilled workforce, which is essential for the sustained economic health of rural areas.

4.3. Strengthening Food Security and Reducing Imports

Local development initiatives can significantly enhance food security by increasing local food production and reducing reliance on food imports. This is particularly important for remote or island communities, where imported food can be expensive and less fresh. For example, community-supported agriculture (CSA) programs in rural Scotland have revitalized local agriculture by ensuring a steady market for local produce, thus encouraging farmers to invest in crop diversification and sustainable practices. This not only secures the local food supply but also reduces the carbon footprint associated with transporting food over long distances.

4.4. Enhancing Community Resilience to Economic Shocks

Moreover, these initiatives enhance community resilience to economic shocks, such as those caused by global pandemics or trade disruptions. By strengthening local food systems and creating diverse economic opportunities, communities are better equipped to handle external shocks. During the COVID-19 pandemic, regions with strong local food systems were able to quickly adapt to disruptions in global supply chains, providing continuous access to food and maintaining local economic stability.

4.5. Promoting Sustainable Tourism

Additionally, agri-food projects can promote sustainable tourism, another vital source of local income. Agritourism ventures that offer farm stays, culinary tours, and local food festivals attract tourists seeking authentic experiences, bringing additional revenue to rural areas. These activities not only boost the local economy but also foster a deeper appreciation and demand for local products, further supporting local agriculture.

5. Funding and Collaboration Networks

The landscape of funding and collaboration in European agri-food research has evolved significantly with the transition from Horizon 2020 to Horizon Europe, the EU’s key funding program for research and innovation for the period 2021-2027. This program aims to tackle climate change, help achieve the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals, and boost the EU’s competitiveness and growth. The program facilitates collaboration across borders and scientific disciplines to drive innovation in agri-food systems and beyond.

5.1. Horizon Europe and Its Strategic Objectives

Horizon Europe significantly enhances the scope and resources compared to its predecessor, focusing on global challenges that affect the agri-food sector. This includes funding for projects that address sustainable agriculture, food security, and the bioeconomy, with a strong emphasis on innovative, green technologies and practices. For example, projects that explore the use of AI in crop improvement or develop sustainable food packaging solutions are prime candidates for funding under this comprehensive framework.

The Crosspaths project is entirely funded by Horizon Europe.

5.2. EIT Food: Fostering Innovation and Education

Another pivotal entity in the European agri-food innovation landscape is the European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) Food. EIT Food is one of the knowledge and innovation communities (KICs) established by the European Institute of Innovation and Technology, which aims to transform the way food is produced, valued, and consumed. EIT Food supports innovative and entrepreneurial initiatives and is dedicated to creating a sustainable, future-proof agri-food sector. The institute focuses on innovation in nutrition, agriculture, and food technology, providing funding, mentorship, and networking opportunities to startups and researchers.

Most of Crosspaths project partners are members of EIT Food.

5.3. Integrating Regional Funding and Collaboration Efforts

Additionally, many European regions contribute to the funding and support of agri-food innovations through regional development funds, such as the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF). These funds often focus on boosting economic growth and cohesion by correcting imbalances between regions. For instance, ERDF has supported the development of agri-food parks that integrate production, processing, and distribution in one location, reducing costs and environmental impact.

The core focus of Crosspaths is to leverage ERDF funded infrastructures into an international network of research institutions to improve their potential to deliver value to stakeholders.

5.4. Leveraging Public-Private Partnerships

Public-private partnerships (PPPs) play a crucial role in leveraging private and public funding to advance agricultural research and development. Initiatives like the Bio-based Industries Consortium (BIC) exemplify how joint investment by the EU and private companies can spur innovation in bio-based industries, including agri-food sectors. These partnerships not only provide financial resources but also facilitate knowledge exchange and market access, which are crucial for the successful translation of research into viable products and technologies.

5.5. The Role of Collaborative Networks

The success of these funding mechanisms is significantly enhanced by collaborative networks that bring together academia, industry, NGOs, and government bodies. These networks are essential for sharing best practices, research findings, and technological innovations. They enable stakeholders to tackle complex challenges more effectively through a multidisciplinary approach, which is often required in the agri-food sector due to its complexity and the interdependence of its various components.

6. Case Study: Resource Efficiency in the Netherlands

The Netherlands has emerged as a global leader in circular economy practices, particularly within the agri-food sector. This small but highly innovative country has successfully leveraged its extensive agricultural knowledge and technological advancements to pioneer recycling and upcycling food waste into valuable bioproducts. Dutch initiatives showcase how agri-food systems can transform waste into worth, thereby setting a blueprint for sustainability that could be replicated worldwide.

One of the key innovations in the Netherlands is the development of biorefineries that process vegetable and fruit waste into new products, ranging from bio-based packaging materials to nutrient-rich animal feed. This not only reduces waste but also decreases dependency on traditional, non-renewable raw materials. For instance, a significant project in this area is led by a consortium that includes academic institutions, government bodies, and private enterprises, which collaborates on optimizing the extraction and purification processes to scale up production of bio-based products.

Moreover, the Dutch government supports these innovations through policies that incentivize sustainable practices among farmers and agribusinesses. Financial incentives, such as tax reductions or subsidies, are provided for companies that invest in sustainable technologies and circular processes. These policy measures ensure that sustainability is woven into the fabric of economic decision-making, promoting a shift towards a more resilient and sustainable agri-food system.

The success of the Netherlands in this area also stems from its collaborative approach to research and development. The country's research institutions are at the forefront of agri-food innovation, working closely with the private sector to pilot and implement new technologies that can lead to sustainable outcomes. These collaborations have not only resulted in technological innovations but also in the creation of educational programs and public awareness campaigns that highlight the importance of sustainability in agriculture.

The leading Dutch research and innovation university is Wageningen University and Research, one of the Crosspaths consortium partners. It ensures that our project can benefit from the knowledge and know-how of a leading institution.

By examining the Netherlands' approach, it becomes clear that the transition to a circular economy within the agri-food sector is not just about technological innovation but also about creating an enabling environment through supportive policies, public-private partnerships, and a strong focus on community engagement and education. This comprehensive approach could serve as a model for other countries aiming to integrate circular economy principles into their agri-food systems.

7. Challenges and Future Perspectives

As the agri-food sector in Europe continues to evolve, it faces a myriad of challenges that must be addressed to ensure sustainable growth and innovation. These challenges span environmental, technological, socio-economic, and regulatory domains, each presenting unique hurdles for stakeholders at all levels.

7.1. Environmental Sustainability

One of the foremost challenges is enhancing environmental sustainability. Despite advances in sustainable practices, the agri-food sector remains a significant contributor to climate change, biodiversity loss, and resource depletion. Efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, improve water management, and enhance soil health are ongoing, but the scale and speed of implementation need to be increased. Future research and innovation should focus on developing and deploying technologies that not only reduce the environmental footprint of agriculture but also enhance its resilience to climate change.

7.2. Technological Integration and Adoption

Technological adoption poses another significant challenge. While there is a surge in innovation, particularly in digital agriculture and biotechnology, the rate of adoption varies widely across Europe due to differences in economic capacity, digital literacy, and infrastructure. Bridging this digital divide is crucial for ensuring that all farmers and agri-businesses can benefit from new technologies. Future perspectives should include tailored support programs that facilitate technology transfer and adoption, especially in less developed regions.

7.3. Socio-Economic Inequalities

Socio-economic inequalities within the agri-food sector also present considerable challenges. Small-scale farmers and rural communities often lack the resources and support needed to compete in the global market. Strengthening local food systems and supporting smallholders through favorable policies, access to markets, and fair trade practices will be essential for creating more equitable food systems. Additionally, ensuring that innovation benefits all stakeholders equitably will require inclusive policy-making and community engagement.

7.4. Regulatory Hurdles

Navigating regulatory frameworks continues to be a significant challenge for agri-food innovations. The regulatory environment can often be slow to adapt to new technologies and business models, potentially stifling innovation. Future efforts should focus on creating adaptive regulatory systems that can accommodate new advancements in food safety, genetic editing, and sustainability practices while ensuring public health and environmental protection.

7.5. Global Supply Chain Vulnerabilities

The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted vulnerabilities in the global food supply chains, emphasizing the need for greater supply chain resilience. Future perspectives might include developing more robust local and regional food systems that can withstand global disruptions. This involves not only diversifying supply sources but also increasing investments in food storage, processing capacities, and logistics.

7.6. Future Directions in Research and Collaboration

Looking forward, fostering collaborative research that spans disciplines and borders will be key to addressing these multifaceted challenges. Horizon Europe and other initiatives like EIT Food provide platforms for such collaboration, but more integrated efforts are needed. Engaging a broader range of stakeholders, including non-traditional partners such as tech companies and social enterprises, can bring fresh perspectives and solutions to the table.

Furthermore, engaging the public in understanding and supporting sustainable agri-food systems through education and transparent communication will help align consumer behavior with sustainability goals. This alignment is crucial for driving demand for sustainable products and practices.

8. Conclusion

The future of Western European agri-food systems is shaped by a dynamic interplay of innovation, collaboration, and a steadfast commitment to sustainability. Emerging trends, such as digital agriculture, circular economy practices, and consumer-centric innovations, offer a roadmap for transforming food systems to meet the challenges of the 21st century. However, these opportunities come with significant challenges, including environmental sustainability, technological adoption gaps, socio-economic inequalities, regulatory complexities, and global supply chain vulnerabilities.

Programs like Horizon Europe and EIT Food, alongside regional funding mechanisms such as the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF), are instrumental in driving research and innovation. These initiatives provide the financial support and collaborative networks necessary to address the sector’s complex challenges. Public-private partnerships and multidisciplinary collaborations amplify these efforts, fostering a culture of co-creation that is essential for developing localized and contextually relevant solutions.

Case studies, such as the Netherlands’ leadership in circular economy practices, illustrate the potential for integrating innovative technologies, policies, and community engagement to create sustainable and resilient food systems. Similarly, co-creation and local development efforts demonstrate how inclusive approaches can empower communities, enhance economic opportunities, and build resilience against global disruptions.

Looking forward, the agri-food sector must prioritize flexibility, inclusivity, and sustainability. Research and innovation efforts need to focus on bridging technological and socio-economic divides, creating adaptive regulatory systems, and fostering local and regional food systems that are robust against global challenges. Public education and transparent communication will play a crucial role in aligning consumer behavior with sustainability goals, further driving demand for eco-friendly practices and products.

In conclusion, Europe is uniquely positioned to lead the global transition to sustainable, resilient, and equitable agri-food systems. By addressing existing challenges and leveraging opportunities for innovation and collaboration, the region can set a benchmark for how agri-food systems can meet the needs of both current and future generations while safeguarding environmental and social well-being.

References

1. Preiss, M., et al. (2022). Trends Shaping Western European Agrifood Systems of the Future. Sustainability.
2. Cioloș, D., et al. (2013). Promoting EU Research and Innovation in Agri‐food. EuroChoices.
3. Hermesse, J., et al. (2023). Co-creative research for transitioning toward a fair and sustainable agri-food system in Brussels, Belgium. Sustainability.
4. Muscio, A., et al. (2020). Are Agri-Food Systems Really Switching to a Circular Economy Model? Implications for European Research and Innovation Policy. Sustainability.
5. Chiaraluce, G., et al. (2021). Circular Economy for a Sustainable Agri-Food Supply Chain: A Review for Current Trends and Future Pathways. Sustainability.
6. Jurczak, R. (2021). Dynamic analysis and forecast of effective development of the agri-food sector of European countries. VUZF Review.
7. Muscio, A., et al. (2018). Technological diversity in Europe: empirical evidence from agri-food research projects. Regional Studies.
8. Iocola, I., et al. (2022). Agroecology research in Europe: current status and perspectives. Open Research Europe.
9. Iocola, I., et al. (2023). Agroecology research in Europe funded by European and transnational programmes: current status and perspectives. Open Research Europe.

‍